| Title | : | Ill Be Seeing You |
| Author | : | |
| Rating | : | |
| ISBN | : | 0553567187 |
| ISBN-10 | : | 9780553567182 |
| Language | : | English |
| Format Type | : | Paperback |
| Number of Pages | : | 208 |
| Publication | : | First published June 1, 1996 |
Ill Be Seeing You Reviews
-
“People can't help the way they look, just the way they act.”
This was cute. Carly is in the hospital after breaking her leg but it's not her first visit - when she was younger, they found her headaches were from a tumor and had to operate. The operation left her changed - her face not the same it was before.
Carly faces the world with humor. It's a little dark and sometimes she over does it, but at least she is facing the world. I think Carly's frustrations with people not being nice and being shallow is still accurate today.
I liked Reba and thought she was a great addition to the story. I also liked Janelle, her sister. Kyle was almost too good to be true but I know he's possible.
The tape player and lack of cell phone or computer/laptop was the only thing to really make this story feel dated. It was cute and I enjoyed it for the quick read it was. -
This romance novel is about a girl named Carley who has a terrible facial deformity. While in the hospital with a broken leg, she meets a boy named Kyle who has temporarily lost his eyesight because of a chemistry experiment that went terribly wrong. The two kind of seem to fall in love, but Carley is too frightened to tell Kyle that she is secretly ugly, and her refusal to see him almost ruins their friendship/romance. I think that Lurlene McDaniel’s intentions in writing this novel were initially good: she wants to appeal to teenagers who are 1) insecure about their appearance, and 2) desperately want a boyfriend and/or girlfriend. I therefore think she’s trying to push for teenagers to be less superficial and accept themselves as they really are, as well as telling them that they can eventually find someone who will love them (romantically) regardless of their outside features. However, McDaniel ultimately undercuts this emphasis on the inside rather than outside person; Carley is an angsty brat—even more so than most teenagers, including myself, which is saying something—who only surmounts the challenge of her facial deformity because she gets plastic surgery. Kyle says he accepts Carley regardless of her appearance, but he is still repulsed by her misshapen face. This novel lacked character development, a coherent plot, or a follow-through in the moral that people should love you regardless of your personal appearance. I didn’t read many romance novels as a teenager, but the ones I did (like Nicola and the Viscount and Victoria and the Rogue by Meg Cabot) at least featured strong female heroines and moral male leads, neither of whom needed plastic surgery to feel good about themselves. I understand why this novel and its attempted themes would seem to appeal to teens; however, for a novel that deals more explicitly and directly with teens coming to terms with the fact that people judge them based on their personal appearance, teenagers and adults should try something like Goth Girl by Barry Lyga or Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson—both of which feature developed characters, interesting plotlines, and problems that aren’t fixed with solutions as easy as Carley’s plastic surgery.
-
Growing up this was on my top 10 list of favorite books. It's a short novel and although I would have loved at least 100 more pages or a sequel, I can't help but love this book. I discovered this book as a teenager and read it all in one night, going to school glassy eyed from not sleeping. hehe.
The story of Carly and Kyle is just lovely. Carly represents so many girls.. If you've ever been insecure about yourself, lack confidence, been teased for the way you look, or have a sister who is gorgeous and standing next to her you fall short, you can relate to Carly. She's this beautiful person in the inside who's outside doesn't reflect that. Scarred and disfigured from cancer to save her life Carly is the "dog-faced" girl. (And before you ask why she just doesn't fix her face with plastic surgery; take into account that this book took place in the early 90s and that no doctor wants to risk working on her face from the amount that had to be cut out of her face.)
- Read the full review on my website:
Love Story Reads -
Sixteen year old Carley suffers from a facial deformity that was a result of having tumor removed from her brain. Though she recovers, she finds herself spending a little bit of time in the hospital again for an unrelated injury, and this is where she meets Kyle. Kyle has gone blind from a science experiment gone wrong, and this gives Carley the opportunity to get to know him without having to deal with her facial deformity. However, she is not completely honest with Kyle, and this ends up being a problem for both of them as the plot progresses. Though many parts of this romance are a little cheesy and cliche, McDaniels does do soem justice to the theme of judging others based on their looks. I think that this book would work really well with younger girls, because then the fact that it is slightly cheesy will not matter quite as much and will be audience appropriate. Still, even though I criticize the cheesiness it is not anything worse than I have already seen in dozens of chick flicks, and so I think that girls will enjoy it as a fun read and will probably relate to Carley's feelings of anxiety over how she looks.
-
Genre: Romance/Lurlene McDaniel
Sixteen-year-old Carly's face is deformed after surgery when she was twelve-years-old. After staying in the hospital for knee surgery four years later, she meets Kyle, a boy her age who has temporarily lost his sight. As Carly and Kyle grow closer as friends, Carly begins to fear Kyle gaining his sight back because she doesn't want him to see her deformed face.
This is the second Lurlene McDaniels book I've read and it is very similar to the first. With poor writing and cheesy lines and plot, it was difficult to get through. However, the issues dealing with boys, healing, image, and self-esteem make it a perfect read for teenage girls. No one dies in the novel like in many of McDaniel's other books, but it ends happily, giving a positive, predictable ending to a perfect teenage romance. -
Sheer rumor: Lurlene listens to police scanners and visits hospitals
during bouts of writer's block.
-
My 1st Lurlene book!! Just LOOK at the absurdity of this cover though. I thought maybe I was ACTUALLY reading a sultry Harlequin romance novel and they are just playing a kinky sex game on the cover 🤣🤣 HE'S NOT REALLLY BLIND, HE'S JUST PLAYING 🤣🤣 But no, he's just TEMPORARILY blind, from a chemistry experiment blowing up in his face. But meanwhile Carley our protag is disfigured from a life-saving surgery to remove a tumor in her nose when she was 12. Poor girl is Quasimodo on the left side of her face but COME ON, wasn't there reconstructive surgery as an option? This was 1996, not 1935!!
Anyway they meet-cute in the hospital and Carley is glad the cute temporarily blind boy Kyle cant see her. She devises a ruse to have her beautiful sister pretend to be her after homeboy persists in having his friends meet her. And then after he gets out of the hospital and wants to meet her, she lies and says she has a boyfriend. All because she doesn't want him to see her sad gnarly face.
Well ultimately he regains his sight and does SEE her, and initially recoils in disgust.... but still wants to get with her! All is ok! She's gonna get her face fixed after all even though that should've been an option 4 years ago and it's also ok that she was a COMPULSIVE LIAR this whole time to him!! 🤣🤣🤣🙃🙃🙃
This was a highly readable book though, and I breezed right through it. I thought it would be overly maudlin and dramatic but it was actually, dare I say, kinda enjoyable! Even though girlfrand was a self-pitying liar, she made up for it by having a sardonic sense of humor and a sharp wit.
4 out of 5 flirty winks from Kyle. HE CAN SEEEEE AGAIN! -
Ketika saya masih kecil ibu saya pernah membelikan majalah bekas Aneka Ria (sekarang Aneka Yes) sebagai bacaan saya. Karena di pasar terdekat tempat saya tinggal hanya ada toko buku kecil yang hanya menjual buku pelajaran saya harus puas dengan majalah bekas. Saya ingat dulu setengah dari isi majalah Aneka adalah cerpen, salah satunya yang saya baca bercerita tentang cowok buta yang berteman dengan seorang cewek yang cacat. Tapi cowok itu tidak tahu kalau cewek itu cacat. Waktu cowok itu bisa melihat lagi, si cewek menyuruh saudaranya yang cantik dan normal pura-pura jadi dirinya. Begitu saya baca sinopsis novel ini, saya langsung tertarik dan teringat cerpen itu yang saya lupa judulnya apa.
Carley, 16 tahun memiliki wajah yang aneh karena proses penyembuhan kanker yang dia derita ketika berusia 12 tahun. Dia tidak pernah berpikir akan ada anak laki-laki yang akan menyukainya apalagi seorang cowok cute macam Kyle. Mereka bertemu di rumah sakit ketika Carley sedang dirawat karena kakinya patah dan terkena infeksi sedangkan Kyle tidak bisa melihat karena kecelakaan yang dia alami ketika melakukan eksperimen kimia. Kyle belum terbiasa dengan keadaannya dan merasa depresi. Tapi Carley yang memiliki rasa humor yang tinggi mampu membuat Kyle menjadi ceria dan mulai membiasakan diri dengan keadaannya. Kyle sangat berterima kasih pada Carley dan terang-terangan bilang suka. Carley juga menyukainya, tapi Carley takut suatu hari ketika penglihatan Kyle kembali, dia akan meninggalkan Carley begitu tahu bagaimana rupa aslinya.
Kalau melihat judul-judul karya Lurlene McDaniel, kebanyakan berisi novel tentang tokoh penyakitan. Saya beruntung memilih novel ini sebagai bacaan pertama karya Lurlene McDaniel. Karena biarpun kedua tokohnya mengalami sakit, tapi ini bukan novel tearjeker. Carley yang memiliki humor yang tinggi menceriakan novel ini. Sama seperti dia menceriakan Kyle yang sedang depresi karena buta. Ceritanya juga punya pace yang cepat dan singkat yang agak mengecewakan saya, karena ceritanya bagus, saya ingin baca lebih banyak. Sangat pas sekali dibaca di waktu luang. Karena ceritanya tidak berat dan tetap memberikan isi. Akan lebih bagus lagi kalau ditambahkan satu bab lagi biar genap 20 bab dan tidak gantung. Karena saya tidak suka akhir cerita gantung. Tapi novel ini sangat bagus. Bisa dibaca dengan cepat dan enjoyable. -
2018
The romance between Carly and Kyle is just beautiful. And I always appreciate a good beauty and the beast story (although in this case the roles are reverse and the damsel is the "dog-face"). But the beautiful thing about this adaption is that the moral of the story goes beyond saying that everyone deserves love no matter what their appearance is, but it also gives us Carly, a girl that most young teens can relate to. Most young girls might feel a little insecure about their appearances, especially in today's appearance driven world, so having someone who feels beautiful on the inside even though she doesn't feel like she looks beautiful on the outside gives them someone to look up to.
The only truly sad thing for me about this book is that the ending isn't long enough! I'm really happy with the way she ended the story (I'm all about happily ever afters), but I wanted MORE! -
I BELIEVE I ONCE READ A LURLENE MCDANIEL BOOK TO THAT EFFECT, BUT I ALSO BELIEVE IT ENDED WITH EITHER THE BLIND DUDE OR THE DEFORMED LADY DYING.
I READ THAT TOO! BUT THIS BLURB IS LYING. THE KYLE GUY DEFINITELY LOST HIS VISION BECAUSE HE WAS FUCKING AROUND WITH ILLEGAL FIREWORKS IN MY COPY. IDT ANYONE DIED.
IL HER WEIRD CATHARTIC GRIEF PORN!
I HAVE SUCH VIVID MEMORIES OF THE ONE WHERE THE UGLY GIRL FELL IN LOVE WITH A BLIND GUY BUT WHEN HE GOT HIS SIGHT BACK INSISTED HER SISTER PRETEND TO BE HER. AND THE DAWN ROCHELLE BOOKS! THEY TAUGHT ME IF YOU BLEED LOTS WHEN YOU'RE THIRTEEN AND SHAVING YOUR LEGS, YOU PROBABLY HAVE CANCER. -
I read this book all in one day and was surprised. It had a good ending!! I was happy about that. This book is very sweet at the end but also in a way annoying because Carley doesn't trust Kyle to still like even after he can see her face which is partially deformed. She lies and even uses her sister to prevent herself from getting hurt. Eventually though after a long time she gets proven wrong in that she thought that Kyle would never go for a girl like her who "isn't pretty." One thing I didn't like was how just when the book seems to be getting good it ends.
-
Another one by lurlene Mcdaniel that i thought to be poorly written. yes, it had a great idea behind it, and the relationship between the main characters was pretty cute. but really, no one acts like that. it was an easy read and i got thru it pretty quickly. wasnt horrible but could have been alot bettter.
-
I really loved this book!! I have read it several times and I just can't get enough of it. Lurlene McDaniel is an amazing writer, she truly understands the hardships that young adults must go through. I have read several of her novels and find them all amazing.
-
The fisrt book that I haven't really cried like a baby from Ms. Mcdaniel great story!!
-
This is the first novel by this author that I've read. I have to say that I became so engrossed in the story that when it ended, I was surprised. Despite this being a young adult novel for older teens, because most of the book takes place in a hospital, I forgot that I was reading a YA novel.
What I enjoyed about this book was the interaction between the characters. I especially enjoyed the two sisters. The relationship, if we can call it that, between Carley and her sister's boyfriend was interesting to see evolve. Carley despises the boyfriend, but the two eventually come to an understanding. Perhaps not all teens can be so forgiving or the other be so aware of their own faults. Regardless of that fact, I'm always happy to see characters grow, evolve and become better people by the last page, even if it's a little bit.
As for Carley herself...perhaps some will find her too much. The lengths she goes to in order to keep Kyle knowing of her facial deformity is maybe over the top. However, even in fiction, I would never presume to know the suffering one person has endured because of a disability.
Some might find Carley's self-deprecating humor too much or corny, but I thought it amusing. In a world that looks bleak, sometimes the only way to get through each day or the hard times is to crack a joke, no matter how silly or corny.
If I had a problem with this book is that it was over too soon. As I mentioned, I forgot it was a YA novel and was enjoying the pace of the story. Then suddenly it was over. I also somewhat feel the ending was anticlimactic in some sense. That's when I read the last line...and then that was it, I felt almost slow and stupid. I couldn't believe it would end just like that. I did have to remind myself, young adult novel, of course. It's not going to go into more detail because that's not how it rolls.
Overall, an excellent novel. Also, as the world of those with visual impairments is no stranger to me, I thought this book did a good job of explanining the limitations and issues that the sight-impaired go through. It wasn't too much, but it was a little bit for those not aware of how those who suddenly lose their sight cope.
Anyway, I would recommend this novel for those looking for a short, light read. I would suggest it for adults and young adutls alike, but with a caution. It might be too teenage-ish for some older folks. And some, like me, might enjoy a humorous read. -
Out of the three books in True Love, i liked this one the best. First of there was humor, since Carly was the type of person to have something funny to say. And then there's Kyle, who's momentarily blind. Carly, despite being "ugly" because of cancer's effect, was a beautiful person, other than the fact that she lied to Kyle, she was a character i liked. And that's why i liked this book. Society these days only like you if you're good looking. You can be the worst actor, singer, etc... and just because of your looks, you'll get to places. I find this really unfair because the public have to view such garbage, but thats the sad truth.
However since Kyle is blind he doesn't know how she looks. He only knows her for her smell, her sexy voice, and that awesome personality of her's. This got me thinking, what happened if everyone was blind? There would be so much people who gets acknowledge for their talents and skills, not their dolled up face and bodies. Imagine if everyone only got to see when they actually know the beauty of something. That would be epic.
There was also a time in the book where Kyle mentions that even though he can't physically, he can see. i found this a very deep oxymoron. But i understood, because i close my eyes to day dream, although my eyes are closed there are still images in my head. Then there was this other time where kyle asked if you ever wished an event wouldn't happen, in his case a rocket blowing at his face (the reason why he's blind), but if that was the cause he would've never met Carly. So even if something bad occurs, something good can come out of it too. Which is why people shouldnt dwell over the past and just build up upon it. -
*Correction 3.5 stars. *
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. Although it was not my favorite Lurlene McDaniel book, It was still pretty well written. My reason for the 3.5 stars is pretty much all because of the ending. Now this review contains Spoilers so be prepared.
I'll Be Seeing You is about a girl named Carley who is in the hospital because of an infection in her broken leg. But there is a catch, she had brain cancer and because of the surgery to remove the tumor from her brain, she is left with a disfigured face. She is stuck to believe that no one will love her or think she is beautiful.
so when Kyle, her next door neighbor is admitted to the hospital, she decides to meet him ; at 3 in the morning.
throughout this book Kyle and Carley form a bond that no one can break. Or can they....
Carley refuses to tell Kyle about her face, so when Kyle finds out the truth it's ugly. Now the reason why I didn't like the ending is because it skipped ahead months in like.. a page turn, and a plane flew over the High School saying 'Carley,be mine. K.W." and then the book ended....
It seriously irritated me and i was just like... What . The . Fuck. -
Carley Mattea had a tumor in her face and now it is very scarred. She is in the hospital because she broke her leg roller blading. She meets Kyle, who was burned in a chemical explosion at school and is blinded. Carley's room is right next to Kyle's so she hangs out with him. She is very self conscious about her face and likes the fact that Kyle can't see her. They become very good friends. Carley's sister Jan is one of her greatest supporters, even masquerading as Carley when Kyle's friends come over.
This book is a good lesson in "beauty is only skin deep." Carley has a fantastic sense of humor, and had me laughing out loud in some areas. She takes great pains to hide her scarred side of her face. I enjoyed the interaction between the characters. They are real teens with exceptional problems. -
I remember reading this book when I was younger and now that I have a daughter who is curious about all the books I read and have read I wanted to go back and find ones that would be perfect for her.
So on that note, this book is perfect for younger girls especially nowadays with how people treat each other and the rude remarks and bullying girls suffer. It teaches them that beauty is deeper than physical appearances. I believe this story is good for those who do suffer with self esteem issues and that it teaches them to not only love themselves but also, to be brave and not shy away.
I gave it a lesser star rating only because I know others along with myself would have liked to see a little bit of a better ending with finding out what exactly happened after the banner but all in all a sweet and easy read -
This was a quick fun read that was granted cheesy and slightly ridiculous, but it had a good message and I have found that these novels have an immense attraction to young teenage girls. This was my first McDaniels book, but my sisters have read dozens of them and absolutely love them. This one is the story of a young girl who has recovered from cancer, but it left her facial deformed. While in the hospital she meets and falls in love with a boy who has been blinded by a chemistry explosion. Their relationship grows, but she is afraid that if his sight returns and he sees her appearance it will all come to an end. This wasn’t my favorite by far, but I would recommend it to reluctant young female readers.
-
This was a good book but I was disappointed in the ending. I wasn't happy about the way that Kyle responded to Carley when he first saw her face. I know she should have told him up front,and I didn't like how she lied to him, but you know it had to crush her the way he reacted when he first saw it and the harsh words he used before he left. I was shocked to read about the event at the very end that brought them back together, but it just left me hanging. I was wanting to know more that would happen. This was a good book, but not one of the ones that I would have to read again or go out to buy a copy for myself to keep. It was a fast read and the typical love story.
-
He lost his sight from a chemistry experiment gone bad. She lost her beauty after a cancer was removed. He finds comfort in her company, but she is determined never to let him see her as she really is.
As far as young adult romance goes, this one is a fair shot. As a blind individual myself, the inevitable clichés were a little annoying, but overall I thought the book made for a decent weekend read. As another reviewer pointed out, the ending could have made for a neater package, but all in all I'm glad I read it.
You may like this book if you read or watched A Walk to Remember. -
This book is so sweet! It is a heartwarming book that also had a valuable lesson to it that beauty is truly in the eye of the beholder. It's what's on the inside that counts, and this book holds that strong value. My one and only complaint about this book is that sometimes the dialogue didn't really sound natural and Carley cracked too many cheesy jokes, but that's easy to look past. This book was really hard to put down and I finished it in 2 days. If you want to read a sweet young adult love story I highly recommend this novel! Lurlene McDaniel books never fail me!
